What really makes good heavy metal art? I've been doing the art for Flesh Socket since the begining, and have recently started doing art for a few other bands here in the City of Brotherly Hate-that-leads-to-Fratricide. And usually I get very positive comments ("Totally brutal man!" or "Fuckin' A man, that's sick!" or the like) on the stuff I do, but I want more. I want to make the kind of cover that will make albums sell themselves.
And some people can be more difficult to work with. I did the cover for our friends Blackmass Mafia's upcoming new album, War Machine. And that was cool, save for a bit of run-around making everyone happy. Now, the lead man from the band, Nuge, is great, totally metal, got the looks and the voice and the attitude. And he only emails me IN ALL CAPS. So metal, man!
So he asked me for "a sick-ass transformer tank robot thing, fuckin' shit up!" Well, I selt him this:
Pretty good, no? Well, I was really happy, and was sure they'd be to, particularly since I was doing all this art for them for free. "That's the cover!" he says, and I thought no more of it. But then I hear that some of the other guys don't like it, and can we have a "beefier" robot? Well, I didn't want to do more than one more, so I sent them sketch after sketch, till I finally hit on one that they liked. Funniest thing? Right after I got the drawing finalized, Nuge fired the rest of the band and hired new members. Musicians, eh? Anyway the new robot looks like this:
More brutal, more 'beefy' and altogeter more metal, I do believe. I'm not as happy with the composition though. But I do like having an eviscerated corpse and a good blood splatter. Gives it a really hard-core feel, very old-school. Which is what the guys form Blackmass where going for, I think. They have that sound. So now, everyone's happy. And check out their new disc when it comes out -- the tunes are GOOD. And it's worth buying for just the art.
If anyone wants that first robot, let me know. He's for sale.
Other than that, I've had great luck, save this one time. A while back, I did a cover for a start up band (that doesn't seem to've come to anything) called Hangmans Cry. He asked me to do a reaper, holding a noose. Now, I said to myself, "That's going to look cheesy no matter what I do," but I said I'd give it a shot. So I thought and thought, and in the end, an idea hit me in the head like a flying wad of bloody cum! I painted the whole thing in a week, and loved it. Sent the guy the drawing, and he hated it.
Look at the painting first, and try to guess why. Here's the drawing:
Give up yet? He said something like "we're not a death metal band... the idea is Hangmans cry too, like, the hangman himself crys, because of the death he has to deal with." Have you ever heard such emo shit? Yeah, me neither. And that means that "hangmans" is some sorry misspelling of "hangmen" as well: did we pass the third grade? Apparently not.
BUT, not to worry, I sent it to my friend Randy from Your Lowest Moment, whom I'd done this logo for a while back:
And he loved it. So, as soon as those guys can find a steady drummer, they'll be recording a full-length disk, and they'll use that cover. I'm glad someone likes it. Because it's awesome. Not that Randy, incidentally, I also went back and forth with a bit, about that logo. Originally, I had a much more 'old school' logo in mind, but when I presented it to him, he expressed a desire for something a bit more 'creeped out' to go with his gore-metal sound. And I obliged. In the end, I like the final version, but the original concept still has a lot of appeal to me:
I think I'll do a really old-school looking logo for Flesh Socket once I'm done with the new t-shirt design I'm working on. That oughta be fun.
So yeah, I'm learning that in heavy metal art, everyone has different ideas, and desires -- and if I'm to work with more than just my band, I need to be more receptive of commentary early in the process. The cost of doing business. I can stop once we rule the world with an iron fist of doom and destruction, and the carbon-based flesh bags have been wiped away like so much snot and cum.
We end with a cthulu: